Almay eye makeup remover pads are ridiculously easy to use, are available at drugstores nationwide and are cheap cheap cheap. The moisturizing pads soothe the delicate eye area with aloe, cucumber and green tea but will remove even stubborn waterproof mascara. These are oily, kinda like when we used to use baby oil, but I like that for the moisturizing effect it gives me. Almay eye makeup remover pads are hypoallergenic, ophthalmologist tested and 100% fragrance free. And you get 80 pads for around $6 bucks! Also available in non-oily.
I purchased this item myself